Warning: if you think that all illegal immigrants should get amnesty, if you think the Dream Act is a good idea, if the California version of the Dream Act made you stand up and cheer, you will not like this post. At all.
Disclosure: I am the grand child of immigrants. Legal ones. My husband is the child and the grand child of immigrants. Again, legal ones. So I see this issue from a little closer up than perhaps the average person.
I recently got into a discussion that turned heated on a forum devoted to fiber preparation, of all things. What was the heated discussion about? Pertussis. Whooping cough, for those of you without a medical background. Why was the discussion so heated? Because I dared to connect the present epidemic of pertussis with the presence of illegals.
Here’s my take on this, or rather these, intertwined issues. When I was a child, there were perhaps 20 total vaccines one was required to have to be fully vaccinated. Today, there are as many as 80 (!). In addition, when I was a child vaccinations were against true killers: pertussis, diptheria, tetanus, mumps, measles, rubella, polio. Today, it’s recommended that children get vaccinations against chickenpox, influenza (yearly!), pneumonia, hepatitis B, haemophilus influenza type B (hIB), genital warts (if you’re a girl) and more. Yes, some of these are killers as well – but honestly, how many children have you heard of that have died from chickenpox?? And does a newborn infant REALLY need to be vaccinated against a sexually transmitted disease like hepatitis B?
I personally think that this increase in the number of vaccines as well as the increase in the variety of vaccines, along with the increase in sedentary activities for children, is what is contributing to the increase in asthma (and hence, influenza and pneumonia related illness and death) in children. I am not alone in my thinking on this, but it is definitely not in the official party line to state such heresy…ah well.
All of my children were vaccinated. Before they went to school. But they were breastfed for a fairly extended period of time, and they were at home with me all day, and they just didn’t have very much exposure to other children until they were close to school age. So with the exception of my oldest son, who WAS vaccinated on schedule and was chronically sick as well – which might have been pure coincidence – my other two were not started on vaccines until they were no longer getting passive immunity from my milk. Let me state unequivocally, I AM an advocate of vaccination. I am just not in favor of blindly vaccinating against things that really aren’t really a risk to an infant, like hepatitis B. Or chickenpox.
So how is this related to illegal aliens? Well, it’s pretty easy, actually. I live in a country that used to be one of the world leaders in free access to vaccinations for the public as a social contract with its citizens. That has changed pretty dramatically since my children were young; now the public health departments are cutting services that used to be considered absolutely vital, including vaccine programs. This particular issue is compounded and confounded by the hoopla over the last 30 years linking the preservatives used in vaccines with autism – a link that apparently has since been proven false. Since my mother was a special Ed teacher, and she is the one who first told me about the possible link nearly 30 years ago, I am not sure this is a closed issue, although I am definitely in the camp that calls Whatley’s study unethical and bad science.
But back to how they are related. Well, in America we had a strong vaccine program for decades. Most of our population was vaccinated, and most of our population, no matter what their income level, got their children vaccinated as well. It was just what we did. As a result, these childhood diseases were nearly wiped out by the time my children were born in the 80′s. In 1983, the year my oldest was born, there were 2,463 cases nationwide. I was unable to ascertain how many deaths there were out of that population; based on this website that contains Swedish data from the same year, it would be less than 1% and of those, 90% are non – vaccine preventable.
Then came the rise of corporatocracy, the rise of consumer culture, of debt culture, and of cuts to public services as they were privatized. And with the loss of faith in the government to protect its citizens came the loss of faith that vaccinating was in the best interests of the average citizen rather than the best interests of the shareholders of pharmaceutical companies who made the vaccines. And along with the rise of corporate greed, research corruption due to that greed, and a massive increase in factory farms as opposed to small farms came a flood of illegal immigrants both looking for an improvement in their living standards and willing to work long hours for sharecropper wages in the fields of those factory farms.
These illegal immigrants came from countries that have never had a strong vaccine tradition; they came carrying disease that, had our children been vaccinated against, would not have posed a public health threat. However, our percentage of children vaccinated has been steadily dropping; the illegals bring their children who do not get vaccinated because the parents are afraid that they will end up being deported if they try to access something like a vaccination program; they put their kids into public school which exposes all of the unvaccinated children to these diseases. This makes for a deadly combination, and makes for much pain and misery all around. The ‘herd theory’ of vaccination is a good one, and it works – IF at least 99% of the population is vaccinated, the 1% who don’t are not terribly likely to be in danger. But add in the fact that nearly 3% of Arizona’s children are not vaccinated based on religious or philosophical grounds, and those who are may not be up to date, and the fact that for some diseases like pertussis you may catch it even if you have been vaccinated – poor nutritional status and stress can contribute greatly to your immunity – and you have the makings of an epidemic.
Arizona actually DID have an epidemic of pertussis in 2005; California in 2010, and both were explicitly connected with the Hispanic population. Here is a link to the California report on the 2010 outbreak; what I think you will see is that poverty plays a role in illness, and that although not stated, the high numbers of illegal Hispanic immigrants plays a large role in this problem in this country.
This last is really not politically correct, but it is true. Sugar coating it doesn’t make it go away. We’re getting poorer, and we’re getting more vulnerable to diseases that were nearly wiped out just 20 years ago. This can only escalate over time. And now that it’s back around, it’s not going to go away; we let that horse out of the barn and it’s not going back in.

